No Magnetic Field on the Axis of a Coil?

Posted on 2006-07-22 as part of the Photonics Spotlight (available as e-mail newsletter!)

Permanent link: https://www.rp-photonics.com/spotlight_2006_07_22.html

Author: Dr. Rüdiger Paschotta, RP Photonics AG

Abstract: Have fun with a tricky physics conundrum: an apparent proof saying that a coil cannot generate a magnetic field on its symmetry axis.

Admittedly, this is somewhat off-topic, but you may nevertheless enjoy to think about a tricky physics conundrum:

Consider a cylindrically symmetric coil with the z axis being the symmetry axis. The magnetic field caused by a current flowing through the coil must also reflect the cylindrical symmetry, so that its <$x$> and <$y$> components must vanish on the z axis. Therefore, Maxwell's equation <${\rm div} \: B = 0$> reduces to <$\partial B_z / \partial z = 0$>, so we see that <$B(z)$> must be constant along the axis. Now we understand that <$B(z)$> must be zero far away from the coil (which of course has a finite extent in z direction), so it must be zero everywhere! In conclusion, there cannot be any magnetic field on the symmetry axis.

This is surely contradicting textbook knowledge, but isn't it convincing anyway?

A hint: if your resolution looks very sophisticated, it does probably not address the crucial point.

Note that the resolution of this issue has been published on 2006-08-18.

This article is a posting of the Photonics Spotlight, authored by Dr. Rüdiger Paschotta. You may link to this page and cite it, because its location is permanent. See also the RP Photonics Encyclopedia.

Note that you can also receive the articles in the form of a newsletter or with an RSS feed.

Questions and Comments from Users

Here you can submit questions and comments. As far as they get accepted by the author, they will appear above this paragraph together with the author’s answer. The author will decide on acceptance based on certain criteria. Essentially, the issue must be of sufficiently broad interest.

Please do not enter personal data here. (See also our privacy declaration.) If you wish to receive personal feedback or consultancy from the author, please contact him, e.g. via e-mail.

By submitting the information, you give your consent to the potential publication of your inputs on our website according to our rules. (If you later retract your consent, we will delete those inputs.) As your inputs are first reviewed by the author, they may be published with some delay.